The Complexities of Self-Tracking – An Inquiry into User Reactions and Goal Attainment

by | May 29, 2015 | Research Publications

Author(s):

  • Sjjklint, Mimmi
  • Constantiou, Ioanna D
  • Trier, Matthias

Abstract:

The activity of self-tracking is an emerging trend that often involves adopting wearable technology. Vendors promise new personal insights and opportunities to optimize health and lifestyle by adopting such devices. Spurred by these promises, users are also driven by curiosity and exploration to adopt and use the device with the aim of quantifying the self for the purpose of self-knowledge through numbers. We investigate the interplay of technology, data and the experience of self during the adoption and use of wearable technology as a pre-commitment device. The empirical focus lies on two self-tracking devices, which track moving and sleeping activities on a daily basis. 42 interviews were conducted with users of self-tracking devices. The findings suggest that self-tracking activity through wearable technology does not necessarily lead to behavioural change, but predominately works as a re-focusing device. In this light, the user experiences tensions between rational and emotional behaviours when reflecting on personal data. The results contribute to a more nuanced understanding of adoption of the emerging wearable technology in daily life and how users deal with the personal data by developing coping tactics, such as disregard, procrastination, selective attribution and neglect.

Document:

https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2611193

References:
  1. I AjzenThe theory of planned behaviorOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, volume 50, issue 2, p. 179 – 211Posted: 1991Crossref
  2. R Agarwal, J PrasadThe role of innovation characteristics and perceived voluntariness in the acceptance of information technologiesDecision Sciences, volume 28, issue 3, p. 557 – 582Posted: 1997Crossref
  3. R F Baumeister, K D VohsWillpower, Choice, and Self-control,” in Time and Decision: Economic and Psychological Perspectives on Intertemporal Choice, p. 13 – 86Posted: 2003
  4. R F Baumeister, J TierneyWillpower: Rediscovering the Greatest Human StrengthPosted: 2011
  5. M H Bazerman, D A MooreJudgment in Managerial Decision MakingPosted: 2008
  6. F Bentley, K Tollmar, P Stephenson, L Levy, B Jones, S Robertson, Wilson, JHealth Mashups: Presenting statistical patterns between wellbeing data and context in natural language to promote behavior changeACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction (TOCHI), volume 20, issue 5Posted: 2013
  7. G Bell, J GemmellA digital lifeScientific American, volume 296, issue 3, p. 58 – 65Posted: 2007Crossref
  8. D M Bravata, C Smith-Spangler, V Sundaram, A L Gienger, N Lin, R Lewis, J R SirardUsing pedometers to increase physical activity and improve health: a systematic reviewJournal of the American Medical Association, volume 298, issue 19, p. 2296 – 2304Posted: 2007Crossref
  9. H BlumerWhat is wrong with social theorySociological Review, volume 18, issue 1, p. 3 – 10Posted: 1954Crossref
  10. G A BowenGrounded theory and sensitizing conceptsInternational Journal of Qualitative Methods, volume 5, issue 3, p. 1 – 9Posted: 2006Crossref
  11. E K Choe, N B Lee, B Lee, W Pratt, J A KientzUnderstanding quantified-selfers’ practices in collecting and exploring personal dataProceedings of the 32nd Annual ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems . Toronto: Canada, p. 1143 – 1152Posted: 2014Crossref
  12. S Consolvo, D W Mcdonald, J A LandayTheory-driven design strategies for technologies that support behavior change in everyday lifeProceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, p. 405 – 414Posted: 2009-04Crossref
  13. I Constantiou, N Hoebel, R V ZicariHow do framing strategies influence the user’s choice of content on the Web?Concurrency and Computation: Practice and Experience, volume 24, issue 17, p. 2207 – 2220Posted: 2012Crossref
  14. I Constantiou, C Lehrer, T HessChanging information retrieval behaviours: an empirical investigation of users’ cognitive processes in the choice of location-based servicesEuropean Journal of Information Systems, volume 23, issue 5, p. 513 – 528Posted: 2014Crossref
  15. R B Cooper, R W ZmudInformation technology implementation research: a technological diffusion approachManagement Science, volume 36, issue 2, p. 123 – 139Posted: 1990Crossref
  16. F D DavisPerceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technologyMIS Quarterly, volume 13, issue 3, p. 319 – 339Posted: 1989Crossref
  17. A Dickinger, A Mitra, D MeyerThe role of perceived enjoyment and social norm in the adoption of technology with network externalitiesEuropean Journal of Information Systems, volume 17, issue 1, p. 4 – 11Posted: 2008Crossref
  18. K M EisenhardtBuilding theory from case study researchAcademy of Management Review, volume 14, issue 4, p. 532 – 550Posted: 1989Crossref
  19. J S B EvansIntuition and reasoning: a dual-process perspectivePsychological Inquiry, volume 21, issue 4, p. 313 – 326Posted: 2010Crossref
  20. Fitbit Official Site for Activity Trackers MorePosted: 2014
  21. M Fishbein, I AjzenBelief, attitude, intention and behavior: An introduction to theory and researchPosted: 1975
  22. A J Flanagin, M J Metzger, R Pure, A MarkoUser-generated ratings and the evaluation of credibility and product quality in ecommerce transactionsProceedings of the 44th Hawaii International Conference of System Sciences (HICSS). Hawaii: USA, p. 1 – 10Posted: 2011Crossref
  23. P B GoesEditor’s comments: information systems research and behavioral economicsMIS Quarterly, volume 37, issue 3Posted: 2013
  24. J G Hixon, W B SwannWhen does introspection bear fruit? Self-reflection, selfinsight, and interpersonal choicesJournal of personality and social psychology, volume 64, issue 1Posted: 1993Crossref
  25. S J Hoch, G F LoewensteinTime-inconsistent preferences and consumer self-controlJournal of Consumer Research, volume 17, issue 4, p. 492 – 507Posted: 1991Crossref
  26. D IhdeTechnology and the Lifeworld: From Garden to EarthPosted: 1990
  27. Jawbone WebsiteJawbone UP: The Path to Better Starts Here. URL: jawbone.com/upPosted: 2014Crossref
  28. D KahnemanObjective happinessWell-being: The Foundations of Hedonic Psychology, p. 3 – 25Posted: 1999
  29. D Kahneman, A TverskyChoices, values, and framesAmerican Psychologist, volume 39, issue 4, p. 341 – 350Posted: 1984Crossref
  30. D KahnemanExperienced utility and objective happiness: A moment-based approachChoices, Values, and Frames, p. 673 – 692Posted: 2000Crossref
  31. D KahnemanMaps of bounded rationality: Psychology for behavioural economicsAmerican Economic Review, volume 93, issue 5, p. 1449 – 1475Posted: 2003Crossref
  32. D Kahneman, Straus Farrar, GirouxThinking, fast and slowPosted: 2011
  33. E KarapanosUser experience over timeModeling Users’ Experiences with Interactive Systems, p. 57 – 83Posted: 2013Crossref
  34. M C Lacity, M A JansonUnderstanding qualitative data: A framework of text analysis methodsJournal of Management Information Systems, p. 137 – 155Posted: 1994Crossref
  35. I Li, A K Dey, J ForlizziA stage-based model of personal informatics systemsProceedings of the Conference on Computer-Human Interaction (CHI)Posted: 2010Crossref
  36. I Li, A K Dey, J ForlizziUnderstanding my data, myself: supporting self-reflection with ubicomp technologiesProceedings of the 13th International Conference on Ubiquitous computing (UBICOMP), p. 405 – 414Posted: 2011
  37. I Li, A K Dey, J ForlizziUsing context to reveal factors that affect physical activityACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction (TOCHI), volume 19, issue 1Posted: 2012Crossref
  38. G M Marakas, S HornikPassive resistance misuse: overt support and covert recalcitrance in IS implementationEuropean Journal of Information Systems, volume 5, issue 3, p. 208 – 219Posted: 1996Crossref
  39. J Metcalfe, W MischelA hot/cool-system analysis of delay of gratification: dynamics of willpowerPsychological review, volume 106, issue 1, p. 3 – 19Posted: 1999Crossref
  40. M B Miles, A M HubermanQualitative Data Analysis. 2 nd editionPosted: 1994
  41. K L Milkman, T Rogers, M H BazermanHarnessing our inner angels and demons: What we have learned about want should conflicts and how that knowledge can help us reduce short sighted decision makingPerspectives on Psychological Science, volume 3, p. 324 – 338Posted: 2008Crossref
  42. M PrattFor the lack of a boilerplate: Tips on writing up and reviewing qualitative researchAcademy of Management Journal, volume 52, issue 5, p. 856 – 862Posted: 2009Crossref
  43. A J Sellen, S WhittakerBeyond total capture: a constructive critique of lifeloggingCommunications of the ACM, volume 53, issue 5, p. 70 – 77Posted: 2010
  44. K ShiltonParticipatory personal data: an emerging research challenge for the information sciencesJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, volume 63, issue 10, p. 1905 – 1915Posted: 2012Crossref
  45. M Sjöklint, I Constantiou, M TrierNumerical representations and user behaviour in social networking sites: Towards a multi-theoretical research frameworkProceedings of the 21st European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)Posted: 2013
  46. K E Stanovich, R F WestIndividual differences in reasoning: implications for the rationality debateBehavioural and Brain Sciences, volume 23, issue 5, p. 645 – 665Posted: 2000Crossref
  47. A Strauss, J CorbinBasics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and TechniquesPosted: 2008
  48. D L Strayer, F A DrewsAttentionHandbook of applied cognition, p. 29 – 54Posted: 2007Crossref
  49. R SuddabyWhat grounded theory is notAcademy of Management Journal, volume 49, issue 4, p. 633 – 642Posted: 2006
  50. J Ritchie, J LewisQualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and ResearchersPosted: 2003
  51. R H Thaler, H M ShefrinAn economic theory of self-controlThe Journal of Political Economy, volume 89, issue 2, p. 92 – 406Posted: 1981Crossref
  52. C Tudor-Locke, D R BassettHow many steps/day are enough?Sports Medicine, volume 34, issue 1, p. 1 – 8Posted: 2004Crossref
  53. A Tversky, D KahnemanJudgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biasesScience, volume 185, issue 4157, p. 1124 – 1131Posted: 1974Crossref
  54. M Vendelo, C RerupSensegiving and crowd safety after the pearl jam concert accidentThe Academy of Management Annual MeetingPosted: 2011