Life Satisfaction, Household Income and Personality Theory

by | Aug 18, 2012 | Research Publications

Author(s):

Proto, Eugenio

Rustichini, Aldo

Abstract:

We show that personality traits mediate the effect of income on Life Satisfaction. The effect is strong in the case of Neuroticism, which measures the sensitivity to threat and punishment, in both the British Household Panel Survey and the German Socioeconomic Panel. Neuroticism increases the usually observed concavity of the relationship: Individuals with higher Neuroticism score enjoy income more than those with lower score if they are poorer and enjoy income less if they are richer. When the interaction between income and neuroticism is introduced, income does not have significant effect on his own. To interpret the results, we present a simple model where we assume that (i) Life Satisfaction is dependent from the gap between aspired and realized income, and this is modulated by Neuroticism and (ii) income increases in aspirations with a slope less than unity, so that the gap between aspired and realized income increase with aspirations. From the estimation of this model we argue that poorer tend to overshoot in their aspiration, while rich tend to under-shoot. The estimation of the model also shows substantial effect of traits on income.

Document:

https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2131159

References:
  1. Mathilde Almlund, Angela Duckworth, James J Heckman, Tim KautzPersonality Psychology and Economics. IZA Discussion Paper, issue 5500Posted: 2011Crossref
  2. Jon Anderson, Stephen Burks, Colin Deyoung, Aldo RustichiniToward the Integration of Personality Theory and Decision Theory in the Explanation of Economic BehaviorPosted: 2011
  3. L B Aknin, M I Norton, E W DunnFrom wealth to wellbeing? Money matters, but less than people thinkJournal of Positive Psychology, volume 4, p. 523 – 527Posted: 2009Crossref
  4. G S Becker, L RayoComment on Economic growth and subjective wellbeing: Reassessing the Easterlin Paradox by Betsey Stevenson and Justin WolfersBrookings Papers on Economic Activity, p. 88 – 95Posted: 2008
  5. D J Benjamin, O Heffetz, M S Kimball, A Rees-JonesAmerican Economic ReviewPosted: 2011Crossref
  6. A E Clark, P Frijters, M A ShieldsRelative Income, Happiness, and Utility: An Explanation for the Easterlin Paradox and Other PuzzlesJournal of Economic Literature, volume 46, p. 95 – 144Posted: 2008Crossref
  7. A E Clark, A J OswaldSatisfaction and Comparison IncomeJournal of Public Economics, volume 61, p. 359 – 381Posted: 1996Crossref
  8. L A Clark, D WatsonTemperament: An organizing paradigm for trait psychologyHandbook of personality: Theory and research, p. 265 – 286Posted: 2008
  9. S Cohen, W J Doyle, R B Turner, C M Alper, D P SkonerEmotional Style and Susceptibility to the Common ColdPsychosomatic Medicine, volume 65, p. 652 – 657Posted: 2003Crossref
  10. D A Cobb-Clark, S SchurerThe stability of big-five personality traitsEconomics Letters, volume 115, p. 11 – 15Posted: 2012Crossref
  11. Paul T Costa, Robert R MccraeInfluence of extraversion and Neuroticism on subjective well-being: Happy and unhappy peopleJournal of Personality and Social Psychology, volume 38Posted: 1980Crossref
  12. A DeatonIncome, Health and Well-Being around the World: Evidence from the Gallup World PollJournal of Economic Perspectives, volume 22, p. 53 – 72Posted: 2008Crossref
  13. R A Depue, P F CollinsNeurobiology of the structure of personality: Dopamine, facilitation of incentive motivation, and extraversionBehavioral and Brain Sciences, volume 22, p. 491 – 569Posted: 1999Crossref
  14. C G Deyoung, J B Peterson, J R Sguin, R O Pihl, R E TremblayExternalizing behavior and the higher-order factors of the Big FiveJournal of Abnormal Psychology, volume 117, p. 947 – 953Posted: 2008Crossref
  15. C G Deyoung, J R GrayPersonality Neuroscience: Explaining Individual Differences in Affect, Behavior, and CognitionPosted: 2010Crossref
  16. G MatthewsThe Cambridge handbook of personality psychology
  17. C G Deyoung, J B Hirsh, M S Shane, X Papademetris, N Rajeevan, J R GrayTesting predictions from personality neuroscience: Brain structure and the Big FivePsychological Science, volume 21, p. 820 – 828Posted: 2010
  18. E Diener, R E LucasPersonality and subjective well-beingWell-being: The foundations of a hedonic psychologyPosted: 1999
  19. Ed Diener, M Diener, C DienerFactors Predicting the Subjective Well-Being of NationsJournal of Personality and Social Psychology, volume 69, p. 851 – 864Posted: 1995Crossref
  20. James S DuesenberryIncome, Saving, and the Theory of Consumer BehaviorPosted: 1949
  21. R A EasterlinDoes Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical EvidenceNations and Households in Economic Growth: Essays in Honor of Moses Abramovitz, p. 89 – 125Posted: 1974Crossref
  22. R A EasterlinWill Raising the Incomes of All Increase the Happiness of All?Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, volume 27, p. 35 – 47Posted: 1995Crossref
  23. R A EasterlinFeeding the Illusion of Growth and Happiness: A Reply to Hagerty and VeenhovenSocial Indicators Research, volume 74, p. 429 – 443Posted: 2005Crossref
  24. A Ferrer-I-Carbonell, Frijters PHow Important Is Methodology for the Estimates of the Determinants of Happiness?Economic Journal, volume 114, p. 641 – 659Posted: 2004Crossref
  25. S D Gosling, P J Rentfrow, W B SwannA very brief measure of the Big-Five personality domainsJournal of Research in Personality, volume 37, p. 504 – 528Posted: 2003Crossref
  26. R InglehartCultural Shift in Advanced Industrial SocietyPosted: 1990Crossref
  27. O P John, L P Naumann, C J SotoParadigm shift to the integrative Big Five trait taxonomy: History: measurement, and conceptual issueHandbook of personality: Theory and research, p. 114 – 158Posted: 2008
  28. O P John, S SrivastavaThe Big Five trait taxonomy: History, measurement, and theoretical perspectivesHandbook of personality: Theory and research, p. 102 – 138Posted: 1999
  29. D Kahneman, A B Krueger, D Schkade, N Schwarz, A A StoneWould you be happier if you were rich? A focusing illusionScience, volume 312Posted: 1908Crossref
  30. D Kahneman, A DeatonHigh income improves evaluation of life but not emotional well-beingProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, volume 107, p. 16489 – 16493Posted: 2010Crossref
  31. Miles S Kimball, Robert J WillisHappiness and Utility. University of Michigan mimeoPosted: 2006
  32. R Layard, G Mayraz, S NickellThe marginal utility of incomeJournal of Public Economics, volume 92, issue jou_issue[1].xmlText, p. 1846 – 1857Posted: 2008-08Crossref
  33. J C LoehlinGenes and environment in personality developmentPosted: 1992
  34. E LuttmerNeighbors as Negatives: Relative Earnings and WellBeingQuarterly Journal of Economics, volume 120, issue 3, p. 963 – 1002Posted: 2005-08Crossref
  35. M McbrideMoney, Happiness, and Aspiration Formation: An Experimental StudyPosted: 2006Crossref
  36. R R Mccrae, P T CostaPersonality in AdulthoodPosted: 1990Crossref
  37. R R Mccrae, P T CostaConceptions and correlates of Openness to ExperienceHandbook of personality psychologyPosted: 1997Crossref
  38. R R Mccrae, P T Costa, JrA five factor theory of personalityHandbook of personality: Theory and research, p. 102 – 138Posted: 1999
  39. J C Moore, L L Stinson, Edward J Welniak, JIncome Measurement Error in Surveys: AReview. Journal of Official Statistics, volume 16, issue 4Posted: 2000
  40. G Ueller, E PlugEstimating the effects of personality on male and female earningsIndustrial and Labor Relations Review, volume 60, p. 3 – 22Posted: 2006Crossref
  41. A OswaldHappiness and Economic PerformanceEconomic Journal, volume 107, p. 1815 – 1831Posted: 1997Crossref
  42. D J Ozer, V Benet-MartinezPersonality and the prediction of consequential OutcomesAnnual Review of Psychology, volume 57, p. 201 – 221Posted: 2006Crossref
  43. D L Paulhus, D C Lysy, Yik, MSelf-report measures of intelligence: Are they useful as proxy IQ testsJournal of Personality, volume 66, p. 525 – 554Posted: 1998Crossref
  44. R Reimann, A Angleitner, J StrelauGenetic and environmental influences on personality: A study of twins reared together using the self-and peer report NEO-FFI scalesJournal of Personality, volume 65, p. 449 – 476Posted: 1997Crossref
  45. B W Roberts, R Nathan, Rebecca Kuncel, Avshalom Shiner, Lewis R Caspi, GoldbergThe Power of Personality. The Comparative Validity of Personality Traits, Socioeconomic Status, and Cognitive Ability for Predicting Important Life OutcomesPerspectives on Psychological science, volume 2, p. 313 – 345Posted: 2007Crossref
  46. P Royston, D G AltmanRegression using fractional polynomials of continuous covariates: Parsimonious parametric modellingApplied Statistics, volume 43, p. 429 – 467Posted: 1994Crossref
  47. A RustichiniNeuroeconomics: what have we found, and what should we search forCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology, volume 19, p. 672 – 677Posted: 2009Crossref
  48. J P SchraplerRespondent Behavior in Panel Studies -A Case Study for Income-Nonresponse by means of the German Socio-Economic Panel (GSOEP)Posted: 2002
  49. C SenikDirect Evidence on Income Comparison and their Welfare EffectsJournal of Economic Behavior and Organization, volume 72, p. 408 – 424Posted: 2009Crossref
  50. A StutzerThe Role of Income Aspirations in Individual HappinessJournal of Economic Behavior and Organization, volume 54, issue 1, p. 89 – 109Posted: 2004Crossref
  51. M R SpoontModulatory role of serotonin in neural information processing: Implications for human psychopathologyPsychological Bulletin, volume 112, p. 330 – 350Posted: 1992Crossref
  52. B Stevenson, J WolfersEconomic Growth and Subjective Well-Being: Reassessing the Easterlin ParadoxBrookings Papers on Economic Activity, volume 1, p. 1 – 87Posted: 2008
  53. L A Vaughn, J Baumann, C KlemannOpenness to experience and regulatory focus: Evidence of motivation from fitJournal of Research in Personality, volume 42, p. 886 – 894Posted: 2008Crossref
  54. J Vittersö, F NilsenThe Conceptual and Relational Structure of Subjective Well-Being, Neuroticism, and Extraversion: Once Again, Neuroticism Is the Important Predictor of HappinessSocial Indicators Research, volume 1, p. 89 – 118Posted: 2002